The cryptocurrency landscape in the United States is on the brink of a regulatory transformation. On June 7, Senators Cynthia Lummis (R-Wyo.) and Kirsten Gillibrand (D-N.Y.) introduced the Responsible Financial Innovation Act (RFIA)—a landmark bipartisan proposal aiming to establish a comprehensive legal framework for digital assets. This article, the first in a two-part series, explores the core components of RFIA, focusing on definitions, taxation, securities and commodities classification, and consumer protection.
By clarifying regulatory boundaries and promoting innovation, RFIA seeks to position the U.S. as a global leader in responsible fintech development. Below, we break down the key provisions in accessible, SEO-optimized language while integrating essential keywords: digital assets, cryptocurrency regulation, RFIA, CFTC, SEC, stablecoins, tax treatment, and consumer protection.
Clear Definitions for Digital Assets
One of the biggest challenges in regulating cryptocurrency has been the lack of standardized terminology. The RFIA addresses this by defining key terms with precision, laying the foundation for consistent enforcement and compliance.
What Is a Digital Asset?
Under RFIA, a digital asset is defined as a natively electronic asset that uses cryptographic distributed ledger technology (like blockchain) to represent economic, property, or usage rights. This broad category includes virtual currencies, ancillary assets, payment stablecoins, and digital representations of securities or commodities.
Virtual Currency
A virtual currency is a type of digital asset primarily designed for use as a medium of exchange, unit of account, or store of value. It must operate on decentralized ledger technology and not be derivative of another financial asset. Notably, the definition includes assets redeemable via smart contracts at face value—blurring the line between traditional crypto and programmable money.
Payment Stablecoins
Payment stablecoins are issued by business entities and pegged 1:1 to fiat currencies like the U.S. dollar. To qualify, issuers must hold sufficient reserves and allow holders to redeem their tokens upon request. This provision aims to ensure stability and trust in digital payment systems.
Smart Contracts
Smart contracts are self-executing code on a blockchain that automatically triggers actions—such as transferring ownership or releasing funds—when predefined conditions are met. RFIA recognizes their critical role in managing and transferring digital assets securely.
Tax Treatment of Cryptocurrency
Tax clarity is crucial for widespread crypto adoption. RFIA introduces several taxpayer-friendly measures aimed at reducing friction and encouraging legitimate use.
Exemptions for Small Transactions
Transactions involving $200 or less in digital asset purchases for goods or services are excluded from capital gains calculations. This small-dollar exemption simplifies compliance for everyday users and promotes crypto as a viable payment method.
Mining and Staking Are Not Taxable Events
Individuals who earn digital assets through mining or staking won’t owe taxes until they sell or dispose of those assets. This aligns crypto taxation with traditional property rules and supports network participation without immediate tax burdens.
No Tax on Crypto Lending
Loans secured by digital assets are not considered taxable events, removing uncertainty around borrowing against crypto holdings.
Broker Reporting Requirements
Building on the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act, RFIA reaffirms that brokers—entities facilitating digital asset transactions—must report user activity annually. However, it clarifies that developers, wallet providers, and validators aren’t classified as brokers unless they facilitate trades.
Safe Harbor for Non-U.S. Nationals
Non-U.S. persons using U.S.-based financial accounts to trade digital assets are granted a regulatory safe harbor, extending existing securities and commodities protections to their crypto activities. This could make American markets more attractive to international investors.
DAOs Recognized as Legal Entities
Decentralized Autonomous Organizations (DAOs) are officially recognized as taxable business entities under RFIA. To comply, DAOs must register as formal legal structures—such as LLCs—under applicable state laws. This brings accountability while preserving decentralized governance models.
Government Guidance and Reporting
The IRS is required to issue clear guidance on complex crypto events like forks, airdrops, staking rewards, charitable donations, and stablecoin liabilities. Additionally, the Government Accountability Office (GAO) must report to Congress on risks associated with crypto retirement investment plans, ensuring policymakers stay informed.
Securities Classification: The Ancillary Assets Framework
One of the most debated aspects of crypto regulation is whether a digital asset qualifies as a security. RFIA offers a nuanced solution by introducing the concept of "ancillary assets."
From Howey Test to Ancillary Assets
While still rooted in the SEC’s Howey Test—which determines if an investment involves an expectation of profit from others’ efforts—RFIA refines this standard for blockchain-based assets.
An ancillary asset is a digital asset whose value depends on managerial efforts but does not confer equity ownership, dividends, or liquidation rights. Think of utility tokens that power decentralized networks but don’t represent corporate shares.
Two-Tiered Disclosure System
- Ancillary Assets: Issuers must file disclosures with the SEC twice per year, providing transparency about project progress and team involvement.
- Fully decentralized assets—those no longer reliant on central actors—are excluded from this requirement and presumed to be commodities, not securities.
This approach creates a path for projects to transition from regulated status to full decentralization over time.
Challenging Misclassification
Courts can override an issuer’s claim that their asset is a commodity if they fail to meet disclosure obligations or exhibit centralized control. This gives regulators a tool to combat bad-faith classification attempts.
👉 Learn how compliant platforms are navigating evolving crypto regulations worldwide.
Commodity Regulation and CFTC Authority
To prevent regulatory overlap and confusion, RFIA clearly assigns jurisdiction over non-security digital assets to the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC).
Exclusive Jurisdiction Over Spot Markets
The CFTC gains exclusive authority over spot markets for fungible digital assets deemed commodities. This prevents conflicting rules from multiple agencies and streamlines oversight.
Registration Pathway for Exchanges
Digital asset exchanges can now register with the CFTC under new guidelines. The bill outlines operational standards, cybersecurity requirements, and bankruptcy protocols to protect users during insolvency.
Fees to Support Oversight
The CFTC may collect minimal user fees from registered platforms to fund its regulatory operations—an innovative funding model that avoids taxpayer burden.
Futures Commission Merchants (FCMs)
FCMs—firms that handle futures trades—are allowed to offer digital asset services, provided they follow strict rules for safeguarding client funds.
Bank-Issued Stablecoins: A Special Category
Stablecoins issued by banks or credit unions are explicitly exempt from both securities and commodities classification. This acknowledges their unique role as regulated fiat-backed instruments within the financial system.
Consumer Protection Measures
RFIA prioritizes user safety through transparency and accountability.
Mandatory Disclosures
Digital asset providers must clearly disclose:
- The underlying source code of each asset
- Whether the asset complies with securities or commodities laws
- Risks associated with holding or trading specific tokens
These disclosures must appear in customer agreements, ensuring informed decision-making.
Final Settlement Terms
Providers and users must agree on final settlement terms before executing any transaction—reducing disputes and enhancing clarity in fast-moving markets.
Right to Self-Custody
The bill affirms an individual’s right to own and manage their digital assets directly. This protects personal autonomy in financial choices and supports non-custodial wallet usage.
👉 See how leading platforms empower users with secure self-custody solutions.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q: What is the main goal of the Responsible Financial Innovation Act?
A: RFIA aims to create a balanced regulatory framework for digital assets that fosters innovation while protecting consumers and ensuring tax compliance.
Q: Does RFIA make crypto tax-free?
A: No—but it introduces exemptions for small transactions and defers taxes on mining/staking income until disposal, making compliance more practical.
Q: Are all cryptocurrencies considered commodities under RFIA?
A: Not all. Only fully decentralized assets or compliant ancillary assets are presumed to be commodities. Others may still be classified as securities.
Q: How does RFIA affect DAOs?
A: DAOs must register as legal entities (e.g., LLCs) to operate legally, ensuring accountability while preserving decentralized governance.
Q: Who regulates crypto under RFIA—the SEC or CFTC?
A: The SEC oversees security-type digital assets; the CFTC has exclusive authority over commodity-type digital assets in spot markets.
Q: Do I need to report every crypto transaction under RFIA?
A: Brokers must report taxable events annually, but small personal transactions (<$200) used for payments are exempt from capital gains tracking.